A MiddleWeb Blog
Imagine, if you will, a picture of me, with a lightbulb over my head. Got it?
What am I doing? Thinking about what to write for my Working Draft blog, right? Right. What were you doing? You were using what is known as “emanata” to translate a visual symbol into a concept. The lightbulb over my head informed your thinking.
The flood of graphic novels into the hands of young readers in the past five years or so has been an amazing shift to watch from the perspective of a classroom teacher. Magnificent works of art – like the Bone series by Jeff Smith and Zita the Spacegirl by Ben Hatke – are transforming the reading experiences of many students, drawing in reluctant readers and connecting art to writing in powerful ways.
I have entire bookshelves in my classroom dedicated to hundreds of graphic novels and non-fiction texts (a perk of reviewing graphic novels is that I get to share them with my students).
Reading graphic stories requires a skill set
While I applaud quality books of any sort, I’ve closely examined how my sixth graders read graphic novels and I’ve talked with them about their experiences on many occasions. I have discovered something interesting along the way: a fair number of my students don’t really know how to “read” a graphic novel because they have never been overtly taught that skill.
Instead, they’ve had parents and teachers simply put graphic stories in their hands, perhaps out of kindness or perhaps out of hope that the reading bug will stick. Graphic stories, however, are more than pretty pictures with text. They are more than a few frames of the Sunday funnies.
There are sublayers present within graphic novels that can make the reading experience confusing for the inexperienced eye. There are elements such as gutters, shifting perspectives, inferential time gaps, dialogue/thinking/text boxes, and more. Scott McCloud explores these ideas in great detail with his various books, including the very influential Understanding Comics.
How I use comics in my classroom
I regularly use comics with my sixth grade students throughout the year. In fact, our first big project is a Dream Scene assignment in which students have to envision themselves in the future and depict their aspirations in an online webcomic space we use called Bitstrips for Schools. It’s a powerful way to begin the year – an engaging art and writing assignment that introduces the rigor of the year ahead. And the Dream Scene projects provide insights into my new students in interesting ways.
As we move through the year, I weave in graphic stories as companion texts when applicable. For example, when we are exploring figurative language and the use of onomatopoeia, I dig out a stack of comic books (from Free Comic Book Day) and my students document the use of sound words to denote action on the pages of Ant Man, Gumby, Spiderman and others.
Finally, we get to the point where direct instruction around how to read graphic novels comes into play. This typically happens when we are reading either The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan or The Mostly True Adventures of Homer P. Figg by Rodman Philbrick. This year we did not use The Lightning Thief, but we recently completed Homer Figg. Philbrick’s use of episodic storytelling as the narrator Homer seeks his brother Harold at the front of the Battle of Gettysburg provides a perfect entry point into making comics.
After the students have read the novel, I give a lesson specifically on the elements of comics. Years ago, I found an activity sheet at Time for Kids magazine that touched on the basics of constructing comics a la McCloud’s theories around graphic stories. Those basics include how to use dialogue and thought bubbles, the use of text boxes, choosing sound words to show action, and understanding some simple emanata ideas.
My overview leads us into closely reading a graphic novel. We use a class set that presents a retelling of The Odyssey, entitled Odysseus: Escaping Poseidon’s Curse by Dan Jolley. Since both The Lightning Thief and Homer Figg are built on the structure of Homer’s epic poem and story, it makes sense to use that as our touchstone text.
Collectively, we go through the graphic novel, page by page, frame by frame, noticing both the story and the format of the story, paying attention to the way the illustrator replays the adventure, the sequence of the story, the elements of time that require reader inference, and how the visual storytelling complements the text storytelling. We explore the art form with critical eyes.
And then my students become graphic novelists themselves.
Writing our own comics
Our lesson involves dividing up The Mostly True Adventures of Homer P. Figg into sections, which we do collaboratively as a class, ignoring chapters in favor of episodes. Once this is done, each student is assigned a section, and their task is to render the novel into a graphic story scene.
While I do provide a basic template for creating a comic, they are free to create their own frames (not many do). They are expected to use some of the ideas we’ve discussed about graphic novel writing in their pieces, and when completed, the pages are put together to create a class graphic interpretation of the novel. Here’s the result:
We need to treat graphic novels seriously
This lesson reminds me that ideas we take for granted — that any student can read and understand a graphic novel, since it is mostly pictures — can lead to false assumptions. My classroom experiences suggest that direct instructions and targeted activities are needed to help students have a meaningful reading experience.
Graphic novels have a lot of potential for emerging and reluctant readers, as well as for those readers looking for challenging texts. I am wary of the recent flood of graphic stories, however; many have clearly been created to ride the wave of interest and money (along with the Common Core-aligned covers).
But when we turn the tables on these pale imitations, using rich graphic stories as our anchor, and then find ways to engage our readers as writers too, the results can be pretty interesting. By giving graphic novels the respect they deserve, we can go fairly deep into many areas of reading comprehension, critical thinking, and writing varied texts.