Reading Comprehension Grades 3-6


Annotated Bibliography

A MiddleWeb Listserv feature

Thanks to listserv member Kathy Renfrew, a Grade 5/6 Multiage teacher in Peacham, Vermont, for preparing this annotated bibliography. A further resource, prepared by Juli Kendall as part of our Reading Workshop project, can be found here. Note that some of the Stenhouse books mentioned here can be browsed in their entirety on-line. Follow the links.



Harvey, S.
(1998). Non-Fiction Matters. Portland, ME: Stenhouse

Non-Fiction Matters offers teachers the tools to assist students to explore nonfiction and to come to a more complete understanding of the real world. Most of the reading adults do is non-fiction but the majority of books found in classrooms is fiction. Non-Fiction Matters offers practical suggestions for the teaching and understanding of this genre.

Chapter Seven, "Reading Non-Fiction: Learning & Understanding (PDF file)," outlines some of the methods teachers can use to promote non-fiction in their classrooms. The chapter then elaborates on the research & the strategies that will assist students in learning to read this genre. It discusses the conventions on non-fiction and provides models for teaching these conventions to students. Techniques for assisting students determine importance in a non-fiction text are also highlighted.

Before this chapter ends. Harvey provides strategies & support for teachers to use with struggling readers. The appendices & bibliographies provide the classroom teacher with effective resources to implement the teaching of non-fiction.


Sibberson, K. & Szymusiak, K. (2001). Beyond Leveled Books. Portland, ME: Stenhouse

Beyond Leveled Books takes a close look at the things teachers do to move transitional readers towards independence in reading. While text levels can be a useful tool in moving toward this goal students can also gain when teachers recognize & use the other supports that texts have to offer. Some of these text supports are text layout, dialogue, and chapter organization.

Chapter 5 focuses on grouping for instruction. There is a chart modeling a typical classroom of students and their most critical needs. The authors take this one step further and demonstrate possible instruction groups in Table 5.1. These groups were developed from the individual needs of the readers. This chapter shows where and how each students is placed in a group.

It also discusses what this means for whole group instruction. Read-alouds are needed to teach strategies that the whole class needs. The intent is for students to take the skills & strategies he/she learns in read aloud and apply them to their guided and independent reading.

Beyond Leveled Books can easily be read, understood, and implemented by classroom teachers.


Robb, L. (2000) Teaching Reading in the Middle School. New York, NY: Scholastic

Teaching Reading in the Middle School provides a strategic approach to teaching reading that improves comprehension and thinking. The fourth chapter in the book " Discover What Students Know About Reading" identifies four types of middle school readers struggling readers, reluctant reader grade level readers, proficient read and the characteristics of each of these types. In this chapter Robb puts forth strategies and supports to assist the classroom teacher learn about their students as readers.

"What's Easy? What's Hard?" provides an opportunity for students to reflect on themselves as readers. Before the students are asked to respond to these questions, Robb models , with a think aloud, how she would go about answering that question. On page 94-95 , she gives complete instructions as well her personal example.

Using a Reading Strategy Checklist is another assessment tool Robb uses to get to know her students as readers. the checklist page 102 is used three times a year. The first time the checklist is used it is a baseline against which students can measure their progress as they work to develop and sharpen their reading strategies.

Teaching Reading in Middle School is a useful book for teachers. The chapters are organized to help teachers implement the strategies they would use them in a classroom.

In this book Robb recognizes and promotes the the idea that teachers must provide their students with opportunities to engage in authentic reading. Teachers must also provide a structure of reading strategies that students can use while reading.


Fountas, I., & Pinnell, G. (2002) Leveled Books For Readers Grades 3-6. Portsmouth, NH: Heineman

Leveled Books for Readers
is the perfect supplement to Guided Reading and Writing. The work in this book builds on the research and work that was done in the first book for these grade levels.

Leveled Books for Readers features more than 6,000 leveled titles for grades 3-6, including fiction & non-fiction in many different genres. Chapter 2, "Leveling Books and Understanding Why," is a crucial chapter for classroom teachers who want to understand the reasoning behind the leveling of works.

An important piece of information from this chapter is figure 2-3, a chart titled "Change in Reading Over Time" (pages 16 &17). The chart demonstrates a continuum from when a reader enters school through the end of elementary school. It gives an detailed explanation of the characteristics of emergent readers, early readers, transitional readers, self-extending readers, and finally advanced readers. These characteristics are correlated with grade level, basal level and text level.

This chapter provides a classroom teacher with a tool to guide readers to "just right" books for independent reading and to provide teachers with an approximate text levels for guided reading.


Hoyt, L. ( 1999). Revisit, Reflect and Retell. Portsmouth, NH: Heineman

Comprehension is a critical issue for all students. It is an issue that classes through all grade levels. In this book Hoyt focuses on thoughtful reflection and retelling as key strategies to improve reader comprehension.

This book is broken into six chapters that contain many strategies and reproducibles that contain excellent resources for teachers trying to improve the reading comprehension of their students.

The essence of this book is that adult readers savor the story, sometimes wishing it could go on forever. Sometimes they rush through the book, impatient for the climax and resolution. When the story does end adult readers might spend some time mulling over scenes they enjoyed or telling a friend about it, but they would not be writing summaries or creating dioramas. Chapter 1 captures the essence of these adult practices, focusing on conversations about books and Oral Retellings.

Hoyt found in her research the importance of providing students the opportunity to talk about what they are learning, ( Braunger and Lewis 1997). She also found a strong connection between oral language and reading comprehension (Clay 1972; Wilson & Cleveland 1985). Conversations help readers find the meaning in the piece of the text. Through conversations readers can compare their thoughts with the thought of someone else about the same text.

The teacher's challenge is creating an environment that supports community conversation, as well as facilitating the conversations to keep them focused on text, and helping students connect their knowledge.

To insure this happens, Hoyt provides thoughtful questions for students to ask each other about books and about being a reader. The remainder of this chapter provides teachers with strategies, instructions & reproducibles to support the strategy.


Teaching Resources website. Laura Candler, site owner (30 Oct. 2001)

This site was created and is kept updated by a Milken Award-winning teacher from North Carolina. Once you are at this page, you can click on any of the file drawers and have access to an array of resources in different subject areas.

Click on "Literary Lesson" and the teacher will find a list of resources having to do with literature circles. Click on literature role sheets and the teacher will have access to reproducible sheets for literature circles. These role sheets are based on the the roles found in Literature Circles: Voice and Choice in the Student Centered Classroom by Harvey Daniels.


Reading Lady website. Laura Kump, site owner (2001)

This site was created by a first grade teacher in Staten Island, New York. A literacy teacher stopping by this site finds himself/herself in a virtual playground with multiple options. At Reading Lady, you can order books, participate in the message board, join a literacy discussion group or just download the free reproducibles.

To get straight to the reading strategies materials, click on the special download icon on the navigation bar at the top of the page. That will bring you to a choice of six different types of printable materials: reader theater, comprehension strategies, six trait writing, 4 blocks, assessment and shareware. After clicking on comprehension, you will be brought to where you can access multiple resources for reading comprehension. If you click on Think Aloud, for example, you will begin downloading a lesson plan for teaching a think aloud. You can choose MSWord or PDF formats.


Reading Online website. International Reading Association (2001)

Reading Online is a journal of K-12 practice and research published by the International Reading Association. The site includes many articles, invited contributions and book reviews. There is a link to book reviews. On the main page site is the current issue, but you can read recent and archived articles by clicking on the articles icon. For a sample, see "Teaching Vocabulary to Adolescents to Improve Comprehension." There is an abstract for each article as well as the full text, with links to resources and bibliography. This particular article includes sample vocabulary intervention activities and games.

Reading Online is an informative website with multiple possibilities for the classroom teacher and a constant flow of new information.


MiddleWeb's Reading Workshop Project. John Norton, webmaster (2001)

This site is divided into 5 sections. The sections include how to become part of the reading workshop project, downloads, a background paper, weekly journals by a Reading Workshop teacher, and access to the daily conversation around the project. The downloads include an independent reading rubric, monthly curriculum maps, retelling rubrics, and more. These are just a some the resources available here.

Fifth and sixth graders who have either been retained or are in danger of being retained are the focus of this project, which is led by Juli Kendall, a reading teacher/coach in Long Beach, CA. Her weekly journal entries describe the work going on in her classroom and point teachers to many resources.


Mosaic: A Reading Comprehension Strategies Listserve
moderated by Jan Geir & Ginger Weincek <>

The site and listserve began in the fall of 2001. It provides a database of books that can be used to teach specific reading strategies, and features an ongoing conversation inspired by books like Mosaic of Thought and Strategies That Work. The site invites participation. If you use a particular picture book to teach a strategy, you can and should document it here. If you go to the site and click on "database" you can choose from several growing categories, including schema, questioning, inferring, synthesizing, determining importance, sonsory imagery, and fix-it up. Previous conversation from the listserv is archived at the site, which will undoubtedly grow in interest and usefulness as more teachers join in.


Ready to Print Resources to Accompany Mosaic of Thought and Strategies That Work Colleen Gallagher, site creator (2001)

The first thing you see when you visit this site is a summary of both of the above-mentioned titles. There are print resources for many types of connections. There is a link for text to self, text to text, and text to world posters. Teachers can also access book titles to use for specific reading strategies as well as a reading quilt activity for students to complete during independent reading. There are many other resources.

And here's a related resource. At this Madison, WI school district page, you'll find downloadable overheads (PDF format) that break down the key elements of Mosaic of Thought in enough detail to use in professional development workshops. An excellent, free resource!

ALSO SEE:

Response Journals Revisited:
Maximizing Learning Through Reading, Writing,
Viewing, Discussing, and Thinking

Les Parsons
Pembroke/Stenhouse Publishers
(2001; 128 pp/paperback)
ISBN 1-55138-131-1

Literature Circles: Voice and Choice in Book Clubs & Reading Groups
Harvey Daniels
Stenhouse Publishers
(2002; 272 pp/paper)
ISBN 1-57110-333-3

Reimagining Reading, A Literacy Institute
Janet Allen
Stenhouse Publishers
(2002; CD or audiocassettes)
ISBN 1-57110-339-2




Back to the MiddleWeb Readers Workshop Project resources page