of interest news diaries chat resources links  
about MiddleWeb


CAROLYN BEITZEL
Diary #20

Real People and Real Lives

Using the PBS online lesson plan for the Civil War, my classes and I were reading a primary document from a soldier named Sullivan Ballou. He was witness to the battle of Manassas in July 1861 and perished before the day was through. He had written a letter to his loving wife about a week before, explaining why he felt it necessary to fight this war and telling her how much he loved her and his children. He seemed prophetically afraid that he was not going to return to her.

I was trying to get the students to understand that once again, history was about real people and real lives. When Ballou died he left behind a wife and two small boys who would never know their father. He had a story to tell and wanted his family to remember him not only for his love for them but his love for his country.

I asked my classes if they knew of anyone who had been deployed to the Middle East or in that area of the world. Several students throughout the day related stories about a "friend of my cousin's ex boyfriend," "my uncle's best friend" or "my father in Germany" who all were involved in one way or another in this new military strategy.

The first class actually asked if they could write letters to service people, like Mr. Ballou wrote to his wife, so they could express their thanks. Wow, what a great idea. I took their idea and offered each class thereafter the same opportunity. It went over great — until my last class of the day.

Some deep breaths

Most of the students in my last class did not want to take our discussion seriously. They could not put themselves in Mr. Ballou's shoes, so I thought maybe they could apply his feelings to a current military event. I was wrong.

When asked what they might ask someone who was in the Middle East or going there to fight one reply was: "Yo. How you doin'?" Another student shouted out, "How's the weather?" and another, "Kill anyone yet?" Definitely not the reaction I was anticipating.

I sat down and literally hung my head and took several deep breaths.
Then I looked them all straight in the eye and said, "I did not think that you would be unable to show feelings for another American who might see combat and die in the process." I also said, "I was sure that you would be able to relate how Mr. Ballou felt about fighting for his country to someone today. You have disappointed me by not taking this task seriously. I would like to try it again."

When I was their age in junior high school I was embroiled in the endgame of the Vietnam War. I watched the news and read the papers. I wore my POW-MIA bracelet proudly everyday, hoping and praying that the soldier fighting "over there" would return. He did not. I glued myself to the television when plane after plane touched down on US soil and returned men and women to a country that did not know what to do with them.

I know that, developmentally, young adolescents are often focused on "me, me, me." But when did our children become immune to world and national tragedy? Is such tragedy so commonplace that another war, another terrorist attack, another health crisis or another burning nightclub is just another everyday occurrence? Or is it that they aren't aware of these issues in the first place?

Our school is collecting pennies for leukemia, a disease that took the life of one of the beloved teachers in our own building. Hasn't the lack of empathy gone too far when we cannot even get them to part with pennies for a cause? Pennies, for crying out loud! Those copper throw-aways that don't buy anything in today's world and collect dust in the junk drawer of our kitchens. My homeroom has yet to donate just one dollar. Neither did I get one can for the food drive at the holidays.

A foreign environment

I was angry with this class and I was angry with myself for getting mad at them.

One student came up to me after class and told me that her brother was in Afghanistan. I asked her, "How did you feel when this class was making fun of people who feel strongly about supporting their government during crisis?" Her reply: "Mrs. Beitzel, it is just one person's opinion. I know how proud of my brother my Mom and I am, and also scared. That's what matters to me." "Didn't they make you mad?" I asked. "Yes, but I didn't want to tell them that," she said.

It is hard to teach in an environment that I personally feel is foreign to me. I struggle everyday to relate to my students. It is so frustrating when I want to take them to another level of learning and they just won't budge from the comfy spot they are in. It is disheartening and discouraging to teach in a place where there is such a lack of fellowship for other human beings. Maybe we do need to stand up for others and ourselves and expect people to start caring again.

No one told me that teaching children would be so hard, emotionally and physically. I am not giving up, however. Those children at my school need me. And I need them as well. They challenge me and help me grow in my profession and as a person. Some days are a little rockier than others. As someone said this week, the strength of a mighty river comes from one raindrop. I am the raindrop.


Comment on this diary entry

Read next week's diary

Read last week's diary


 

 

 

 

newsletter signup
join our discussion
search & site map
contact us

 

Carolyn's Diary Index

Carolyn's background article

 

DIARY INDEX

 

interest news diaries chat resources links home