A Halloween Teacher’s Self Evaluation

A MiddleWeb Blog

kids_cusp2Earlier our Kids on the Cusp blogger Mary Tarashuk took a break from her series of reflections on New Jersey’s new teacher self-assessment rubrics to share a different take on personal performance. We enjoyed it so much we thought we’d share it again this year – in advance of the popular holiday!

Halloween was more than a week ago. I am still recovering. Dia de Los Muertos is a multi-faceted kind of day in elementary education. It’s not all about sugar, but sugar anticipation is in the air…and eventually, the sugar wears off. I am referring to myself, of course. Halloween candy has become a Tarashuk food group in the days following the school-wide celebration.

Our first round of parent-teacher conferences follows Halloween every year. This year, I have 23 kids. Each conference takes about a half an hour – some tougher ones a bit longer. The candy helps on the nights when we have evening conferences to accommodate working parents. (My daughter’s teacher scheduled ours for 7:50 a.m. to accommodate my teaching schedule. It’s what we do. Come to think of it, I should have brought him some candy…)

But first there’s The Day . . .

trick-or-treatersAt the upper elementary level, we begin to see the evolution of rebellion, as a handful of tweens stand up to no longer being “little kids” by declaring that wearing costumes cannot be considered “cool” (Is it still cool to say, “cool”?)

Even so, every child in my class wore a costume this year, and each had a raised energy level upon arrival on Halloween morning. From a teaching standpoint, I know there are some teachable moments to fill before the annual Halloween parade, which begins at approximately 1 p.m. The kids know that too. They also know, in a few hours, they will be scampering through the neighborhood begging for candy, flashlights in hand.

It’s 8:30 a.m. on a school day. But the reality is, it’s Halloween. The curriculum isn’t my focus on October 31st. It’s a day that calls for the trick-or-treat style of teaching. I choose the “trick.”

The objectives are not clearly posted for students to see. That goes out the window on All Hallow’s Eve. This doesn’t mean good learning can’t be present, though. I just try not to let the kids know that we are doing “work.” They don’t want to hear it on Halloween. I simply trick ‘em into learning something new.

Jack ‘o Logic Board

This year, I used an old stand-by. It’s a sample logic problem I found at least a decade ago called “Jack ‘o Logic.” A scanner and a Promethean Board helped introduce a logic grid (and the idea of logic in general). They were distracted from the afternoon parade as we began to “not work” at school.

jack-o-logicOctober is a good time to introduce logic problems. I use them as one very basic type of anchor activity. I need to keep independent learners occupied with something valuable so I can free myself from whole-group classroom management. I need to make time for small-group instruction.

“Jack ‘o Logic” is an activity I found on a previous Halloween in The Mailbox or another teacher magazine somewhere back in time. It engaged my students then and has continued to do so throughout the years. New isn’t always better.

The use of an interactive board is something new for me, but I am feeling more comfortable with this form of technology as I progress. Still, I’m a novice and I don’t put on an expert mask with my kids and pretend I know what I’m doing. They are often much better at manipulating today’s technology than I am. They do get a kick out of my not knowing exactly what I’m doing. (Always!)

A variety of student commentary is provided as an aid to my understanding and effectiveness, and to poke fun. They laugh at me en masse when I hit the wrong command. They enjoy my learning curve, and I know we’re laughing with each other as we try to blend old-school teaching methods with new opportunities to embrace technology.

Storytelling’s in my skill set

halloween-faceThere’s no need for a Promethean Board if you’ve developed the art of storytelling. “Clankity-Clank”, a spooky tale I found years ago at the Flesh Farm website (shiver), is most effective when the blinds are closed, the lights are off, and a flashlight is illuminating my face from below the chin. Halloween is supposed to be creepy. This particular story doesn’t contain blood and gore, though. It’s pure suspense.

As this story of a gravedigger unfolds, we find that he has stolen gold coins from a woman he was supposed to bury. She comes looking for them. As I read, I slowly lean forward, extending my hand in a blind search for my stolen gold coins. Suddenly, she screams, and with a sudden lunge, close to 23 shrieks escape, as many of those huddled on the rug jump back in fright.

I know I didn’t really scare them. I surprised them with my sudden movement and my dramatic change in tone and volume level. But that’s a form of story-telling that enhances our Halloween experience. Common Core? It serves as a model for good reading, use of voice inflection, and assistance in making text-to-scream connections. After the fright interlude, we burst into laughter and popped the lights back on.

Acceptable levels of lunacy

After a quick history discussion about our celebration of this ancient Celtic tradition, the modern tradition of our schoolwide Halloween Sing-Along commenced. This annual event offers an opportunity to keep the haunted hype going within an atmosphere of controlled chaos. It can be fun, but the teacher in me must remain ever-vigilant, monitoring behavior and maintaining an acceptable level of lunacy. The lunch dismissal bell is a welcome sound in years when the balance of bedlam and order gets slightly off-kilter.

Halloween trick or treating childrenAfter the lunch break, as the parade hour approached, we were greeted by an unexpected thunderstorm. It started pouring. Hundreds of parents (simultaneously attempting to locate prime real estate around our school’s grass strip perimeter) got caught in it. Hundreds of students were returning to school after going home to don their costumes. A sumo wrestler, a boxer, a cave girl, and an elaborately tiered mobile birthday cake scooted into the classroom shortly after the rain began.

After numerous intercom announcements, alerting us to up-to-the-minute information regarding the status of the parade, the rain stopped. The parade would go on; albeit not exactly as planned (this seems to be an ongoing theme in teaching).

Once the flashbulbs and the paparazzi thinned, we returned to our room to “bob for donuts.” This involves tying donuts to strings and attempting to eat these swinging sweets. Kids with their hands held behind their backs, happily being bumped in the face by orange iced donuts, is a sight to be seen. They were craning their necks to attack their sugary prizes from a new angle (this activity improves flexibility and eye-mouth coordination in young learners).

Belly-laughing on Halloween really should be a required standard in schools. Maybe we can learn a lesson from a day without any “real” schoolwork.


Mystery and fun can be in our classrooms long after Halloween has passed, if we remember to keep the spirit of learning and laughter alive. But parent-teacher conferences need to be held. The holiday masks must come off, and the process of learning and assessing student growth must continue. Student progress must be discussed. That’s okay. I’ll get through it. I have a candy bar or two stuffed in my desk, in case of emergency.

Mary Tarashuk

Mary Tarashuk teaches 4th grade at Wilson Elementary School in Westfield, New Jersey. Mary has been an educator for over 20 years. She has served as content writer and creative consultant for the national, award-winning initiative The Walking Classroom since its inception in 2005. Mary’s work has been published in Education Digest and was honored with the SmartBrief Education 2016 Editors’ Choice Content Award. Trying to balance her old-school teaching style with New Age methods that integrate ever-changing technology keeps her on her toes. She believes that fresh air and exercise enhance learning and engage students of all ages. Follow her on Twitter @maryrightangle and visit her personal blog (launched in 2021) Behind the Doors of the Teacher's Room for some adult conversation.

2 Responses

  1. Mr P says:

    Love your writing style. So engaging. Well done. “Acceptable levels of lunacy” and “text to scream”. You are a scream!!

  2. Thank you, Mr. P!…days like Halloween help me remember the need for lunacy…and it seems to be a job requirement in education!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.