How Middle School Kids Rejected Stereotypes
This article and video, created by 8th graders at Liberty Middle School in Madison, Alabama, first appeared at the Alabama Best Practices Center blog.
NOTE: This student project stemmed from an 8th grade language arts class at Liberty Middle School reading The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton. We spent many months discussing how we can “shatter” stereotypes in our society. The video features the song “Iron Doors” by The Lighthouse and the Whaler (used with permission). – Ambra Johnson, language arts teacher
What We Are: Shattering Stereotypes
by Devin Acklin, Joyce Jung, Justin Locke & Sara Thorsness
The “I Am” wall originally started as a language arts class project for individual students to shatter the stereotypes that they felt have been placed on them. Before starting on the project, we personally felt confused and unenthusiastic towards this prompt, because it seemed awkward projecting our personal struggles in front of teachers and peers.
“Why should I share my life with others?” It seemed invasive and uncomfortable because students aren’t normally prone to sharing their troubles in a public environment.
One day, Ms. Johnson had us all write down ways that we are judged – personal stereotypes – the things that we are NOT – on strips of black and white paper. We moved our desks to a circle, and Ms. Johnson laid out all of the stereotypes (the “I am not…” strips) in the center of the room. We had no idea who wrote what on each piece of paper, but we silently read those words and phrases scattered across the floor:
I AM NOT …. always quiet / boring / just a band nerd / rich / a know-it-all / Muslim / helpless / who you think I am / always happy / racist / sure of myself / an American native / often included / indestructible / easy / afraid to live my dreams / always trying my best / a loser / fake / listening to you scream at me / a Christian / perfect / and so on.
Ms. Johnson asked us to reflect on what was lying on the floor. We could pick any three strips of paper that we could relate to the most, and we had to write about why we connected to those words. We then had to write about how we can shatter these stereotypes or explain some of the ways we can show the world we aren’t these things.
This was a little bit awkward because we aren’t used to teachers asking us to think this deeply about something that is not really “school related,” but after we got comfortable, everyone started writing and didn’t stop until she made us.
The “I Am” statements
After the first activity, we focused on the things that we really are. The “I am. . .” statements. We tweeted articles and videos on Twitter using the hashtag #lmsthinksbig about different stereotypes of different people.
For example, one day someone tweeted a news article about how adults (you) consider Generation Z (us) “lazy” and “apathetic.” We had conversations in the classroom with each other and with others via Twitter—other students, our assistant principal, a parent, a retired guy in Kentucky we didn’t know – about why teens are judged like this.
The use of Twitter really enticed us as students to take interest in participating in the activity and motivated us to start taking actions to change the world.
Building the wall
Next, we began to make “I AM…” statements to create a wall outside of room 114. If you come by and look at our wall, you will see such a wide variety of words and phrases:
a person / funny / creative / full of anxiety / biracial / an overthinker / trying to find the right path / tired / faithful / reliable / different / bilingual / heartbroken / wanting more / real / a person with anger issues / minus two grandparents / Indian / afraid of meeting new people / misunderstood/ Christian / someone who makes mistakes / athletic / Egyptian / adopted / ADHD / artistically disabled / pressured / tired of cancer / talented / about to crumble / a brother and a son / forgiving / a person who laughs to keep from crying / a dreamer / here for you / a Mormon / stressed / unsure of where I belong / persistent / a person with anger issues / heartbroken / constantly worrying / here for a purpose / clumsy / sad / Turkish / younger than you / trying to find the right path/ bad with change / unwanted / trying my best to learn English / vulnerable / insightful / more than you think I am…
At first, the wall seemed insignificant because it looked like there was no organization or focus or concern for more emotional and abstract connections. However, as the project progressed, we believe that it acted as an eye opener to others’ similar issues.
It was fun to see students from other teams coming up to our hallway wanting to add to our wall, asking for paper and sharpies, reading what was already up there, and really being interested in it. As the wall continued to grow, different students from Team 8 would be in charge of recording using the iPad to document the wall going up. It seemed like the school was taking notice of us and our statements.
More people started coming up to us, asking us what it was and asking about #lmsthinksbig. As awareness grew, our classes bonded closer together, and we think our peers genuinely began to learn what it meant to empathize with others. We can’t speak for the teachers, but it is obvious that other students’ struggles were not so different from our own.
A new perspective on the project
A few weeks after starting the project, our team started reading The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton in class, and this is when we started realizing where all of this stereotyping stuff came from. The main characters in the novel are labeled because of their social class.
We didn’t realize it at the time, but when we were making statements such as “I am labeled,” “I am worried about my future,” “I am courageous,” “I am unsure of my potential,” “I am scared,” “I am sometimes hiding behind my sadness,” “I am a dreamer,” “I am looking for solid ground,” etc., we were writing the same statements that Ponyboy Curtis, Dallas Winston, or Johnny Cade would have written if they were sitting in Ms. Johnson’s language arts class. By picking out “I am…” and “I am not…” statements from the walls about each character, this really made us look at the project and the characters from a different perspective.
The purpose of the wall is to eliminate stereotypes and appreciate the differences in others. If we could describe this wall in one way, it would be “bravery” because students had to be so brave to put personal things on a wall in school where everyone can see.
We learned that we are all alike much more than we realized. It is awesome to see our friends retweet pictures and the video of our wall. Ms. Johnson emailed a band from Ohio called The Lighthouse and the Whaler to see if we could use one of their songs, “Iron Doors,” for our video. They agreed, and a few weeks later they started tweeting with us and even retweeted our video which is awesome because they have a lot more followers than we do, so people in different parts of our country are now watching our video.
We keep discovering things
The wall has stretched beyond room 114, Liberty Middle School, and even Madison, Alabama. We have learned about “digital citizenship” and “global citizens” and things like that, but we think this a real example of taking those terms and applying them to show everyone how our voice can be heard.
We are very proud of the project because it took a lot of courage and hard work to complete it. Well, complete may be the wrong word. We don’t think it will ever be completely complete. It seems that we keep discovering things about ourselves every day, so all we need to strive for is to be ourselves. There is no one exactly like us out there, and this wall serves as a visual representation and reminder to us to “stay gold” and to always “be” us.
Amazing work, great pairing of activities with The Outsiders. Thanks for sharing. I learned a lot from reading the article and watching the video. I love the way eighth graders are so honest. A really trusting and caring environment must have been created. Great work!
nice job. Thanks for sharing this inspiring, authentic, and relevant project!
Great project for all the participants, I’m sure! From an outsider’s perspective, I love, love, LOVE the write-up explaining the process. To Devlin, Joyce, Justin, and Sara: you represented your class, and your school beautifully here! As compelling as the video is, for me your writing really helped me understand the project and some of the feelings people experienced. Well done!
Delvin, Joyce, Justin, and Sarah,
Thank you so much for sharing about your project. It is so helpful for us to hear about the amazing classmates and your outstanding teacher. What a powerful message to turn the destructive “I am not” messages into positive “I am” messages. Beyond that, you learned broader lessons about digital citizenship and finding your voice as writers. Thank you for sharing those lessons!
hi you are cool
Good way to connect students with reality. Grayson County Middle School in Ky is doing a similar project with our advisory groups. Thanks for the idea and the video.
This project sounds truly fascinating. You say you’re not sure the teachers learned as much as the students but I would bet that they did! I love the generative way that this project developed and that it will never be truly complete. Thank you for sharing. You’ve given me lots of ideas that I can use with my students.
Hi Liberty Middle Schoolers,
My 8th grade classes are making a wall like yours because we were so inspired. We’ll send you a picture or vid when it is finished.
Wendy Thompson teacher Branciforte Middle School Santa Cruz, Ca 95062
Love this idea! I’m starting The Outsiders and think this is perfect project to get kids thinking about stereotypes. Keep up the great work LMS
What a fantastic project and you are truly leaders! Such a loud message being seen and heard through your words and actions….. thank you!
This was such an inspiring project. The video had a strong impact on me as a teacher and a parent. I applaud the teacher for creating the environment for the work to be done, and the students for their honesty and willingness to open up and share.
How did you adhere the strips to your wall? Tape? Did it stay up for a long time? How long? Did you have trouble with the strops falling down? I’d like to do this in my school, but would like to cover all of my bases beforehand. Thank you,
I love this! I hope it is ok to replicate this with my 5th graders. I work in a very impoverished community and my students face adversity every day. I am always looking for ways to facilitate activities where the students can lift themselves up and encourage one another.
Please feel free to adapt this project to your community and grade-level needs, Olivia!
Doing this with my 8th graders in Seattle! Great idea and very inspirational
This is very inspiring, good job
HI! This is absolutely amazing and beautiful! I am doing this project but modifying it a little. I am teaching a class of 9 students all with intellectual disabilities who are in a post-secondary program at Longwood University. My class is on self-determination, we are focusing all about who we are as a person. I just love this idea and I am thrilled to have found it! I hope I can share some photos with you all next week!